Song without end is the only existing
movie about Liszt which was created with a biographic attempt. It is supposed
to be a plot of Liszt's life between the 1830s and the 1860s. The conditions
in which the movie was created explain why it was not a frank success.
Originally meant to be directed by Charles Vidor, it was finally realized
by George Cukor, after Vidor's death. When Cukor arrived on the stage where
almost everything had already been set up, he had great difficulty to assign
new directions starting from a project that lookes more like a carricature
of Liszt than anything else. A lot of details were changed, but the final
version remains far enough from reality. A lot of historical inaccuracies
remain in the final version, the figure of Dirk Bogarde as the leading
actor is questionable, mainly because his physical appearance has nothing
in common with Liszt. Bogarde's acting is quite good though, especially
for a non pianist actor. The other characters are for some a sucess (particularely
the two leading women Marie d'Agoult and Carolyne von Sayn-Wittgenstein),
for some a carricature (George Sand, Richard Wagner).
The movie won an oscar for the best sound track,
and it is really remarkable. In fact the choice of Jorge
Bolet as pianist was visionnary for the
time, for he was to become later one of the most famous Lisztians of the
80's. The movie is indeed a delicious summary of the pianistic art of Liszt,
ranging from the Benediction de Dieu dans la Solitude to the Hungarian
Rhapsodies. The outdoor scenes are sometimes accompained by orchestral
pieces such as Mazeppa or the Mephisto Walz. In addition, the acting of
Bogarde is very well filmed, and one coulc from time to time believe he
is actually performing the pieces...
Review ( Synopsis from All-Movie Guide,
from B&N) : Hoping to recapture the success of its 1945 Frederic
Chopin biopic A Song to Remember, Columbia Pictures concocted the 1960
Technicolor costume drama Song Without End. Dirk Bogarde is cast as musical
genius Franz Liszt. Bogarde's piano scenes are dubbed over by Jorge Bolet,
but this hardly matters in that the film is preoccupied with Liszt's infamous
romantic entanglements. The crux of the matter is Liszt's desire to wed
the already married Russian princess Carolyne (Capucine), which will
necessitate an unpleasant breakup with his current lover, Countess Marie
(Genevieve Page). This is the sort of musical biography where everyone
speaks Fluent Name-Dropping: "Hello there, Chopin," "How is your novel
coming, Madame Sand?" and so forth. Director Charles Vidor died after only
a few weeks on the picture; he was replaced by George Cukor, who
graciously insisted that Vidor be billed in letters larger than his. The
chief selling point of Song Without End is its wall-to-wall music; the
film won an Oscar for "best musical arrangement." Hal Erickson
Liszt appears in other movies, some of them related
to music, some others related to characters of the XIXth century. A very
original example is the 1943 version of the Phantom
of the Opera, with Claude Rains as the phantom.
In fact, it is quite amusing to see that Liszt is unwillingly the cause
of the transformation of Rains into the Phantom, helping to steal his music
without knowing it. More than that, he is the key factor to catch the Phantom
in the caves and catacombs of the Paris Opera, performing on the stage
the stolen concerto of the Phantom, which is forced out of his silence
by the music. Liszt in that movie is played by Leiber, which recreates
the Abbe Liszt quite sucessfully...
Liszt is also present through his music in various
cartoons, for example the Cat Concerto, with
Tom
and Jerry. This hilarious cartoon pictures
the cat trying to play the second hungarian Rhapsodie on the piano, while
the mouse is doing a lot of nonsense on the keyboard, the strings and the
hammers...